The pieces in this exhibit were collected by the founders of the Museum, Edward Drummond Libbey and Florence Scott Libbey, on a trip they made to Egypt in 1906. They bought 239 ancient Egyptian artifacts and art works, including Mummy of an Old Man and Mummy of a Young Priest, for the new museum they had founded five years earlier. The exhibit guide notes that the Libbey's added two rooms to the original museum on Madison and 13th Street to show their collection, which proved very popular. It's a piece of Toledo history, among many, that I never knew and am happily just learning.
An excellent guide to the exhibit, with thoughtful & studied commentary on the meaning of "cultural appropriation" and "the ethics of exhibiting mummies." |
From the 19th century to the present day, imagery from ancient Egypt has been appropriated for architecture and design, advertisement, cosmetics, plays and novels and popular culture. As the guide thoughtfully notes "Appropriation, or the borrowing and alteration of images and cultural heritage, changes the context of what you see and what it means. It can cause us to lose sight of the real people and rich history of a culture/civilization in favor of stereotypes and misunderstandings." This is a caution well worth considering. I greatly appreciate its inclusion in the guide.
The two mummies the Libbey's purchased from Egypt are on display. They are the focus of the exhibition, which considers mummies in the context of Egyptomania, while also examining their original role within ancient Egyptian religious beliefs. (All information about the exhibit from the Museum guide or panel notes and descriptions accompanying the art.)
It is fascinating to read about the modern techniques used to study and identify mummies. For instance the mummy of the young priest was first thought to be a woman until Xrays and genetic testing confirmed otherwise. Radiocarbon dating determined that the mummy was a young man, about 20 years old when he died in about 800 BCE. He was almost certainly a priest because his head and body were completely shaved for ritual purification. Art scholars also learned that the pose of the mummy--hands crossed across the chest--is a position known only for men.
The other mummy, the old man, dated to 50-150 CE when Egypt was part of the Roman Empire. Xrays and other studies determined he was about 45-55 years old when he died, about the average life expectancy for his time. The details of his entombment revealed a life of heavy labor and signs of bone problems and arthritis. Imagine being able to uncover such details.
I pondered the art of the dead and the science of life. The ancient Egyptians believed that death began a journey to the afterlife, where all the necessities of their former lives, including their bodies, would be essential to eternal survival. The grand story of the god Osiris and his resurrection, a belief common across religions as Joseph Campbell reminded us, was the source of the ancients belief that life continued in another sphere after death. My brother Loren believed this, and since his sudden death from a heart attack in May 2010 I want to believe it too.
These beliefs of course are sacred. They need to be taken seriously, respected. Fittingly, the Museum, on the cutting edge of museum practice, addressed the issue head on in a large interpretive panel titled "The Ethics of Exhibiting Mummies." The panel notes that when the Libbeys purchased the items for their Egyptian collection it was common to exhibit mummies as scientific and cultural curiosities. In recent decades, however, "there has been a world-wide dialogue about respect for national cultural patrimonies and reverent treatment of the remains of the dead, whether ancient mummies or more recent burials of indigenous peoples. In addition, the display of human remains in an art museum prompts its own questions of appropriateness."
Kudos to TMA for giving viewers a context for understanding this exhibit and enriching our museum experience.
Ah Egypt, we wish you the glories and beauty of your antiquity as you move into an uncertain future. Thanks to TMA for its sensitive portrayal of the Mummies and for keeping the stories and the memories alive.
Some Egypt Blogs at www.fran-ukrainian-adventure
http://fran-ukrainian-adventure.blogspot.com/2011/01/art-and-architecture-for-dead-egypt.html
http://fran-ukrainian-adventure.blogspot.com/2011/01/eqypt-seductive-our-whimsical-hostels.html
No comments:
Post a Comment